336-471-5660michael@michaelgayconsulting.com
Property & Casualty Insurance Expertise

Defensible insurance opinions. Grounded in industry practice.

Michael Gay, CPCU, provides independent expert witness and litigation consulting services to plaintiff and defense counsel nationwide.

Consulting and testifying expert since 2008, serving plaintiff and defense counsel.

40+ yearsInsurance-industry experience
Plaintiff & defenseIndependent case evaluation
NationwideConsulting and testimony
CPCU + 7Professional designations
Areas of Focus

Insurance expertise built for the questions attorneys face.

The work begins with the policy, the record, and the relevant insurance-industry practices—not a predetermined outcome.

01

Agent & Broker Standards of Care

Evaluation of producer conduct, placement practices, documentation, renewals, and professional responsibilities.

Explore this service →
02

Coverage Analysis

Clear explanation of policy language, endorsements, exclusions, limits, and the mechanics of property and casualty coverage.

Explore this service →
03

Agent E&O & Negligent Procurement

Analysis of applications, proposals, communications, coverage requests, recommendations, and alleged gaps.

Explore this service →
New · Fixed Fee $2,500

Agent & Broker E&O Preliminary Case Assessment

A focused review and concise written assessment for plaintiff and defense counsel evaluating potential claims, defenses, and next steps.

Explore the $2,500 Assessment
A disciplined approach

Complex insurance issues explained plainly.

Attorneys, courts, and juries should not have to speak “insurance” to understand what happened.

  • Document-driven review of the complete factual record
  • Analysis grounded in policy language and industry practice
  • Opinions stated clearly without improper legal conclusions
  • Preparation for deposition and trial testimony
  • Timely attention to disclosure and filing deadlines

“I go where the facts take me.”

Michael Gay’s experience spans underwriting, brokerage, agency management, program administration, risk management, consulting, and insurance education. That breadth provides a practical view of how insurance transactions are actually handled.

Meet Michael Gay
What counsel can expect

Independent analysis that holds up under scrutiny.

Clear

Technical insurance concepts translated into direct, understandable language.

Defensible

Opinions tied to the evidence, relevant policy provisions, and accepted practices.

Objective

The same disciplined evaluation whether retained by plaintiff or defense counsel.

Have an insurance matter to evaluate?

Start with a confidential conflict check and preliminary discussion.

Request a Conflict Check